Perceptual demonstration
The shifting smile
Move your gaze across her face. The smile appears to grow when you
look at the eyes, and flatten when you look directly at the mouth.
You are not imagining it.
Leonardo painted the corners of the mouth in sfumato — soft,
low-frequency brushwork with no hard edge. Peripheral vision, which
is tuned for exactly that kind of signal, reads more of an upturn
into the blur than foveal (direct) vision does. The expression
changes because your visual system changes, not the picture.
Research: Margaret Livingstone demonstrated this in 2000 by
filtering the painting into spatial-frequency bands. The smile
lives almost entirely in the low frequencies — invisible to direct
scrutiny, vivid in the corner of your eye. This scene simulates
that acuity falloff so you can feel it happen.